Lightning strikes twice: UKIPO finds likelihood of confusion between competing device marks

The UK Intellectual Property Office (UKIPO) has upheld an opposition brought by Film Finder Ltd (Film Finder) against an application by Snapselll Limited (SnapSelll) to register a lightning bolt device mark for software and online marketplace services.

The decision serves as a reminder that differences in stylisation may not be enough to avoid a likelihood of confusion where competing figurative marks share the same dominant concept and overall visual impression.

The dispute

The application concerned the below yellow lightning bolt device:

The mark was filed in relation to a range of software products, online marketplace, advertising and promotional services in classes 9, 35 and 42.

Film Finder opposed the application based on its earlier UK trade mark registration for:

The mark covers software and advertising-related services.

Film Finder argued that the parties' marks were highly similar and that the relevant goods and services were identical or highly similar. SnapSelll contended that its mark was distinguishable because of its embroidered, three-dimensional appearance and “gold patch” styling, creating a different overall visual impression.

Goods and services

The hearing officer had little difficulty finding that the majority of the class 9 software goods were identical. Many of the applicant's specifications were found to fall squarely within the broader software and mobile application terms covered by the opponent's earlier registration.

In class 35, the applicant's advertising and marketing services were also considered identical to the opponent's corresponding services.

Comparison of the marks

The central issue was whether the differences in presentation of the lightning bolt devices were sufficient to avoid confusion.

The hearing officer concluded that the overall impression of both marks was dominated by the lightning bolt device itself. Although the applicant's mark incorporated additional styling, texture and a three-dimensional appearance, these elements were regarded as reinforcing the lightning bolt concept rather than creating a separate distinctive element.

Importantly, the hearing officer considered the difference in background colours to be of limited significance. Relying on established authority concerning black and white registrations, he noted that a mark registered in black and white may notionally be used in colour. As a result, the colour differences between the competing signs did not materially affect the assessment.

Visually, the marks were found to be similar to a high degree. Conceptually, they were held to be identical because both conveyed the same idea of a lightning bolt. An aural comparison could not be undertaken as both marks were purely figurative.

Distinctiveness of the earlier mark

SnapSelll argued that a lightning bolt is a commonplace symbol in the technology sector and therefore inherently weak, however, no supporting evidence was filed. The hearing officer was not persuaded that consumers would view a lightning bolt as descriptive of software goods or advertising services and concluded that the earlier mark possessed a medium level of inherent distinctive character.

This aspect of the decision demonstrates the importance of evidencing claims that a particular symbol or sign is commonly used in the relevant market. Assertions alone are unlikely to carry significant weight.

Likelihood of confusion

Taking into account the identity and similarity of the goods and services, the high degree of visual similarity between the marks, the conceptual identity of the signs and the earlier mark's medium level of distinctiveness, the hearing officer found a likelihood of direct confusion.

The decision emphasises that consumers are unlikely to retain a detailed recollection of graphical nuances. Minor differences in texture, shading or presentation may therefore be insufficient where the same dominant device is reproduced in both marks. The hearing officer considered that consumers would be likely to misremember or imperfectly recall the marks and mistake one for the other.

The opposition succeeded in full against the class 9 and class 35 goods and services, with the application proceeding only in respect of the unopposed class 42 services.

Practical lessons for brand owners

This decision provides a useful reminder that figurative marks should be assessed holistically. Businesses seeking to adopt simple device marks, particularly symbols such as lightning bolts, stars, arrows or circles, should not assume that stylistic embellishments alone will create sufficient distance from earlier rights.

The case also demonstrates the evidential burden facing parties who seek to argue that a particular symbol is weak or commonly used within a sector. Without clear evidence of widespread third-party use, the UKIPO may be reluctant to reduce the inherent distinctiveness of an earlier mark.

Get in touch

Related