From HYROX to Toblerone: IP in the news

Image of a lawyer reviewing documents.

Intellectual property law continues to evolve at pace, driven by developments in AI, digital content and increasingly creative approaches to brand protection. We explore the latest disputes and trends, from trade dress and shape-based branding to AI-generated likenesses and copyright challenges, highlighting the issues rights holders should keep on their radar.

Trade dress and tarnishment: Dallas Cowboys cheerleaders target My Chemical Romance

In October, the parent company of the Dallas Cowboys cheerleaders filed a petition in the US to prevent the band My Chemical Romance from infringing DCC's cheerleading uniforms. Interestingly, the allegations went beyond copying distinctive elements. The petition alleges both 'trade dress infringement and 'trade mark dilution by tarnishment' as part of their claims.  Background dancers in MCR's first Hollywood Bowl show were reportedly handed semi-automatic rifles and joined a staged firefight. The case serves as a reminder that infringement disputes are not always centred on similarity alone but can also arise where that similarity links a brand to a message, cause or image that it does not consider consistent with its identity.

Built on performance – HYROX defends its name

Having registered their first trade mark in Germany in 2018, HYROX has rapidly become synonymous with fitness racing and endurance events. A local organisation under the name 'Hyrox Association of Macau' has not only used the HYROX name for its own competition scheduled in February but has also adopted a race format strikingly similar to HYROX's: an 8-kilometre run interspersed with eight workout stations. The Macau group has acknowledged the connection, yet intends to proceed with the February event, creating a rare situation in which the similarity is not disputed. Whether HYROX chooses to take enforcement action will be one to watch.

"Synthetic Twin" agreement highlights growing personality rights concerns

The Australian footballer Cristian Volpato has partnered with California-based technology company Callandor, which is currently building an AI intellectual property registry in tandem with a licensing platform for the sports industry. The product emerging from this deal has been described as a 'synthetic twin', with the company having exclusive rights to Volapto's digital likeness, voice, and biometric profiles. Fans will reportedly be able to enjoy interactive experiences with Volpato's digital double, including personalised coaching sessions.

Though this initiative remains in its pilot phase, it highlights the growing commercial opportunities presented by AI-powered personality licensing. For public figures, synthetic twins may offer a convenient way to engage with fans and participate in endorsements without the time commitment associated with in-person appearances. However, the arrangement also raises important questions regarding consent, control and the application of rapidly evolving laws governing digital likenesses and personality rights. Rights holders will need to carefully monitor how these AI replicas are used to ensure that their activities remain consistent with the individual's reputation, personal brand and existing endorsement arrangements. The balance between commercial exploitation and protecting an individual's identity is likely to become a key legal and reputational challenge.

Toblerone v The O’Bar

The triangular shape of the Toblerone bar remains one of the most distinctive 3D product designs in confectionery branding, if not in consumer goods more broadly. When court proceedings were filed in October at the High Court by the owner of Toblerone against vegan chocolate company Catherine's Originals, the dispute highlighted an important aspect of passing off and shape-based brand protection: the allegedly infringing product does not need to be an exact replica.

Catherine's Originals' O-bar is not perfectly triangular. Instead, it consists of a series of rounded, semi-oval peaks. Nevertheless, Toblerone's owner alleges that the overall appearance of the product evokes the famous Toblerone shape closely enough to create an association in consumers' minds. In response, founder Catherine Dodd has maintained that the design reflects the "O" in the O-bar branding and forms part of the company's wider visual identity, rather than an attempt to recreate Toblerone's iconic mountain-inspired silhouette.

The dispute raises broader questions about the scope of protection afforded to distinctive product shapes. If a shape need not be copied exactly to trigger allegations of passing off, where is the line drawn between creating a product with its own visual identity and using a shape that consumers may nevertheless associate with an established brand?

The Gruffalo illustrator claims AI breaches copyright

Following on from Penguin Random House's lawsuit filed against OpenAI, alleging ChatGPT copied the popular children's character The Little Dragon Coconut, The Gruffalo may be the next children's storybook character to feature in the growing debate around AI-generated likenesses. Illustrator Axel Scheffler is reportedly considering action against AI companies over what he describes as the "clear theft of copyright" of the beloved character. Scheffler is considering bringing claims in his native Germany, where courts have recently favoured creators seeking to protect their works from unauthorised AI use. However, such claims continue to be determined on their individual merits rather than under any blanket prohibition on AI-generated reproductions. As AI continues to learn from widely available online images and develop at pace, creators are facing increasing pressure to act quickly to protect their works from unlawful reproduction.

Get in touch

Related